“Speak No Evil” brings back memories of the 1980s-’90s era thrillers made with average budgets like “The Hand that Rocks the Cradle,” “Unlawful Entry,” and “Fatal Attraction” in which members of respectable bourgeois society were in danger from outsiders who detected weakness or wanted to avenge real or imagined wrongs.
Written and directed by James Watkins (“The Woman In Black”) who uses a Danish original which is more grim but has the same title, it remains a fun film that audiences will enjoy, especially on a Friday or Saturday night when the theater is crowded with fans who won’t hesitate to shout, “get out of there, you dummy,” at the screen. The film may be useful to the therapists who explain their patients that they ought to concentrate on the voice informing them that they should leave the abusive partner and not let oneself be persuaded to stay. There are many lesson learning instances here, and several involve the making and use of weapons from scratch.
The main characters are a family from the United States who have relocated to London due to work and personal issues, but are currently experiencing a crisis. The Daltons, Husband Ben Dalton (Scoot McNairy), Wife Louise Dalton (Mackenzie Davis) and their mid-teen daughter Agnes (ALix West Lefler), are even more hurt because of a family betrayal whose particulars will be revealed in the end when the Daltons are locked in a pressure cooker situation somehow.
That would be the unforeseen and entwining arrival of another family which comprises of a forty something father and physician called Paddy (James McAvoy) and his much younger Eastern European wife Ciara (Aisling Franciosi) and their son Ant (Dan Hough) who is approximately the same age as Agnes but has unclear speech due to an abnormality in tongue which Paddy refers to as a birth defect. The families go on vacation in Italy where they meet and, thanks to some chemistry, end up getting to invite the Daltons to discuss over some spacious yet old and run down house Paddy has a few hours out of London.
They are reportedly planning to spend the time together eating meals at home, swimming at the local pond, going for walks in the woods, and many other activities that are likely to be enjoyable until you realize that the people you are supposed to be the most hospitable and have a different notion of hospitality that is quite distressingly so, which is sooner than you would have thought anyway.
Audiences’ patience with pathetic attempts at inflicting comedic inventions or severity starts with this segment. Some of the scenes filmed in the picture show the Daltons indulging in the heinous habit of watching others trespassing, for instance where Patrick is trying to compel a vegetarian Louise to take a morsel of roast goose or where Ciara feigns oral sex to yell at a dining table, “What the hell! How did this happen?” and wish to rush away from these individuals as swiftly as possible. If you are wondering, this is the main point of enjoyment for most, if it is the sort of thing that entertains you, the ambiguity and frivolity of words, as the daltons provide some interesting drama, watching them talk themselves into remaining in a horrible position or coming back after having left it and went digging deeper and deeper, as they say, every time a little deeper into the muck.
As previously stated, “Speak No Evil” is a movie that has its roots in a Danish film made in 2022 by Christian and Mads Tafdrup. Now, very few got to get ahold of it, but if you did, you are quite possibly incensed at what has been done to it. The result is reminiscent of those behind the scenes narratives, mostly accompanying the making of something related to the thriller category in both the 80s and 90s, that say the filmmakers had a great conclusion which was actually very disturbing but when the test audiences were shown the film they went out of their mind saying something along the lines of that the villains should have died a slow painful death and therefore some more shooting took place and a lot of money was made and everyone walked out thinking this was the right thing to do as they had made a lot of money. To some extend fans and lovers of international psychological horror arthouse films may view the first “Speak No Evil” as well as its version and compare it to the events of around three decades ago when “The Vanishing” or “Spoorloos” was made which was a dutch movie whose director later remade the same movie in the united states with a more happy ending.
The original “Speak No Evil” was widely praised, rightfully so, but managed to only recoup about a third of its budget during its box office run due probably to the fact that it featured one of those conclusions that were appropriate in context from a thematic standpoint but made you wish you could go home and hide under the duvet for the next 48 hours.
Watkins’ adaptation sticks closely to the original until the ending which is much longer than the initial version and allows the Dalton’s to overcome their family issues that almost tore their family apart, all this while protecting themselves from their hosts with hammers, guns, and other household items.
The vast majority of thrillers of this sort end with a struggling small number of the characters who are locked in a life or death situation in a dimly lit house. ‘Speak No Evil’ is one of those films that end up going for the cliche with all weapons blazing. Here, as well, one can view it with this distinction, as audience picture. I was having lots of laughs (with the film, sometimes even at it) with the scene where Watkins was attempting to remake the English rural thriller Straw Dogs with a reversal of roles with the characters from the original film. There is quite the build up to Davis’ energetically sexual performance during this generation. There are also a few scenes where she and McNairy understand each other without uttering a single word in a scene, and an entire hour of notes from family therapy can be envisioned in just that extended glance.
All the performances can be described as excellent and nearly perfect as well. It is also beneficial that three of the four leads (McAvoy, McNairy, or Davis) have faced such characters, if only in terms of their plot functions; you know what you’re dealing with these actors because they will find nuances in what you thought was a situation that would only have one resolution.
Montgomery engages the audience in an intriguing fashion. Over the years, he has more or less transformed into some kind of movie star, and here, he utilizes his dark yet coy charm, which can sometimes be reminiscent of an early Russell Crowe performance, where you were never quite sure if you were bidding your time in the midst of a rough, decent bloke or the monster that resided within. Paddy’s both.
The sympathies towards his insecure self, the petty sensitivity towards any perceived insult, the grandiloquent externalized feelings of love for the wife and kid are, on the face of it, extremely genuine sentiments harbored by him. But there is always the subtext that makes it impossible to either defend or sanctify him: the film knows that a human being can love and claim to love their family and their children and still be one of the scum-whoever walked the surface of the earth. Davis and McNairy and, to a lesser extent, Franciosi (only because her character is comparatively underwritten) act as support and/or foils for McAvoy’s grinning jack in the box energy in Dalglish’s movie.
As for the film’s pattern of ‘rescuing’ the Daltons from their own selves, only to show them colluding with their abuser to play the part of the good. Well, such is the case in an abusive relationship. The structure of the film exhibits the same cycle. I don’t know if that is enough not to have such persons complaining that these people had a dozen chances to get out of that place for good and never did, it did not quite work for me, to be very frank. But I believe that the filmmakers understood what they were trying to explain, and it is relevant when discussing the advantages and disadvantages of the film.
For more movies like Speak No Evil visit 123Movies.